CTGE 7845: Curriculum Models: Bilingual/ESL Programs

CTGE 7845: Curriculum Models: Bilingual/ESL Programs

Introduction

Bilingual and English as a Second Language (ESL) programs are crucial for helping students whose first language is not English to become proficient in the English language while maintaining their first language. This article will provide an overview of the various curriculum models used in bilingual and ESL programs and their advantages and disadvantages.

Definition of Bilingual and ESL Programs

In bilingual and ESL programs, students receive instruction in their first language and English to facilitate their acquisition of English language proficiency. These programs are designed to help students maintain their cultural and linguistic identities while acquiring English language skills.

Bilingual Programs

Bilingual programs are designed to provide instruction in both the student’s first language and English. The goal of these programs is for students to become bilingual and biliterate, which means they can read, write, and speak in both languages.

ESL Programs

ESL programs are designed to provide instruction in English only. The goal of these programs is for students to become proficient in English language skills, including reading, writing, listening, and speaking.

Types of Bilingual and ESL Curriculum Models

There are several curriculum models used in bilingual and ESL programs. The following are the most common models.

Transitional Bilingual/ESL Model

In the transitional bilingual/ESL model, students receive instruction in their first language and English for a limited time. The goal is for students to acquire English proficiency quickly and transition to English-only instruction.

Maintenance Bilingual/ESL Model

In the maintenance bilingual/ESL model, students continue to receive instruction in their first language while also receiving English instruction. The goal is for students to become bilingual and biliterate.

Dual Language Immersion Model

In the dual language immersion model, both English-speaking and non-English-speaking students receive instruction in both languages. The goal is for all students to become bilingual and biliterate.

Sheltered English Instruction Model

In the sheltered English instruction model, students receive instruction in English only, but teachers modify their instruction to make it comprehensible to students who are not yet proficient in English.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Bilingual and ESL Curriculum Models

Each curriculum model has its advantages and disadvantages. The following are the most common advantages and disadvantages.

Transitional Bilingual/ESL Model

Advantages:

• Provides students with support in their first language while learning English
• Helps students become proficient in English quickly Disadvantages:
• Students may not develop strong first language skills
• May not provide long-term support for bilingualism

Maintenance Bilingual/ESL Model

Advantages:

• Helps students maintain their first language while learning English
• Provides long-term support for bilingualism Disadvantages:
• May take longer for students to become proficient in English
• May not be appropriate for students who do not have a strong first language

Dual Language Immersion Model

Advantages:

• All students become bilingual and biliterate
• Provides long-term support for bilingualism Disadvantages:
• May not be appropriate for students who do not have a strong first language
• May be difficult to implement in schools without enough bilingual students

Sheltered English Instruction Model

Advantages:

• Provides support for students who are not yet proficient in English
• Allows students to be in the same classroom as English-speaking peers Disadvantages:
• Students may not develop strong first language skills
• May not provide long-term support for bilingualism

Conclusion

Bilingual and ESL programs are essential for helping students who are not native English speakers become proficient in the English language while maintaining their cultural and linguistic identities. The curriculum model used in these programs depends on the school’s resources, student population, and goals.

Conclusion (Continued)

Each curriculum model has its own set of advantages and disadvantages. The transitional bilingual/ESL model is effective for students who need to learn English quickly, but it may not provide long-term support for bilingualism. The maintenance bilingual/ESL model, on the other hand, helps students maintain their first language while learning English, but it may take longer for them to become proficient in English. The dual language immersion model is ideal for students who want to become bilingual and biliterate, but it may not be appropriate for students who do not have a strong first language. Finally, the sheltered English instruction model provides support for students who are not yet proficient in English, but it may not provide long-term support for bilingualism.

It is important for schools to carefully consider the needs of their students and community when choosing a curriculum model for their bilingual and ESL programs. By providing effective bilingual and ESL programs, schools can help students achieve academic success while also maintaining their cultural and linguistic identities.

FAQs

1. Can bilingual and ESL programs be effective for students who are not native English speakers?

• Yes, bilingual and ESL programs can be very effective for students who are not native English speakers. These programs provide support for students to become proficient in English while maintaining their first language.

2. What are the advantages of bilingual and ESL programs?

• The advantages of bilingual and ESL programs include helping students maintain their cultural and linguistic identities, becoming bilingual and biliterate, and achieving academic success.

3. Are there any disadvantages to bilingual and ESL programs?

• Yes, there are some disadvantages to bilingual and ESL programs, such as the potential for students to not develop strong first language skills or for certain curriculum models to not provide long-term support for bilingualism.

4. How can schools choose the best curriculum model for their bilingual and ESL programs?

• Schools should consider their resources, student population, and goals when choosing a curriculum model for their bilingual and ESL programs. They should also consult with experts and stakeholders in their community.

5. What is the goal of the dual language immersion model?

• The goal of the dual language immersion model is for all students to become bilingual and biliterate in both their first language and English.

Top of Form